From black-box ads to 425 new customers in 90 days

Australian supplements and wellness brand. Shopify, Google Ads. November 2024 to September 2025.

  • Shopify
  • Google Ads
  • Google Merchant Center

Summary. An Australian supplements brand on Shopify rebuilt its product pages, tracking and product feed before scaling Google Ads. Between 29 June and 27 September 2025 it recorded 425 new customers, 600 orders and $119,529 in net sales, on about $28,600 of Google Ads spend. Google Ads was the only paid advertising; Shopify Email ran alongside.

new customers
425
net sales
$119.5K
orders
600
of customers buying for the first time
76%
in store revenue for every $1 of ad spend
$4.18

Shopify and Google Ads, 29 June to 27 September 2025. Store-wide results.

Shopify report showing $119,529 in net sales over 90 days.
Shopify sales report, 29 June to 27 September 2025. Store details removed.

The starting point

When I started in late 2024, the brand was running Google Ads Express, a fully automated campaign where budget was the only real control. Underneath it, the Shopify store was missing the basics. Product pages said little about why the product was worth buying, reviews sat on a separate page, there was almost nothing to build trust near the buy button, and the tracking couldn't be relied on to make spending decisions.

Turning the budget up would have been the obvious move. It would also have sent more paid traffic into a store that couldn't convert it.

The decision: fix the store before scaling

I recommended putting the buying experience and the tracking first.

Over the following weeks we rebuilt the product pages around what buyers needed to know, moved reviews next to the products, added trust signals near the buy buttons and cut heavy images so pages loaded faster. Behind the scenes I set up Google Tag Manager, cleaned up the tracking and fixed the product feed. Merchant Center had flagged products as ineligible, which is common in health categories, so that had to be worked through with Google too.

The ads were paused for three weeks in February 2025 while the new store went live and was tested.

Timeline from automated ads in late 2024 to measured results in September 2025. Late 2024 Automated ads on an unready store Feb 2025 Ads paused for three weeks,new store goes live Mar 2025 Relaunch with structured campaigns Jun to Sep 2025 Results measured in Shopify

Then a different kind of campaign

The automated campaign was replaced with structured Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns, set up to favour new customers and organised by product so I could see what each one was doing.

Google's own reports were used to diagnose campaigns. Decisions were made on Shopify's numbers: how many new customers we were winning, what each one was costing, and whether total revenue was growing against what we spent on ads.

What changed, before and after
Before After
One automated campaign, budget the only control Structured Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns
Thin product pages Product pages built around what buyers need to decide
Reviews on a separate page Reviews next to the product
Tracking that couldn't be trusted Tag Manager set up and tracking cleaned up
Products flagged as ineligible Healthy product feed
Google's numbers as the scorecard Shopify's new customer and revenue numbers as the scorecard

What happened

Between 29 June and 27 September 2025, Shopify recorded 425 new customers, 600 orders and $119,529 in net sales. First-time orders ran at 30 to 48 a week in 10 of the 13 weeks, and three in four customers in that period were buying for the first time.

Google Ads was the only paid advertising. Shopify Email ran alongside it: automated flows, plus an end of financial year offer to existing customers around 30 June, with reminders in August. Those emails show up as the three jumps in returning orders on the chart.

Orders by week: first-time and returning

Weekly orders over 13 weeks. First-time orders outnumbered returning orders in 12 of the 13 weeks. 0 30 60 90 48 39 29 Jun 34 11 6 Jul 30 11 13 Jul 33 3 20 Jul 36 4 27 Jul 21 8 3 Aug 16 29 10 Aug 34 32 17 Aug 47 11 24 Aug 27 7 31 Aug 34 6 7 Sep 31 8 14 Sep 34 6 21 Sep Email offer Email offer
Orders by week, 29 June to 27 September 2025
Week First-time Returning Total
29 Jun to 5 Jul 48 39 87
6 Jul to 12 Jul 34 11 45
13 Jul to 19 Jul 30 11 41
20 Jul to 26 Jul 33 3 36
27 Jul to 2 Aug 36 4 40
3 Aug to 9 Aug 21 8 29
10 Aug to 16 Aug 16 29 45
17 Aug to 23 Aug 34 32 66
24 Aug to 30 Aug 47 11 58
31 Aug to 6 Sep 27 7 34
7 Sep to 13 Sep 34 6 40
14 Sep to 20 Sep 31 8 39
21 Sep to 27 Sep 34 6 40
Total 425 175 600
Shopify daily export, 29 June to 27 September 2025, grouped by week. 425 first-time orders and 175 returning orders, 600 in total.

Google Ads spend over the same 90 days was about $28,600, or roughly $9,500 a month. Across the store, every dollar of ad spend was matched by about $4.18 in revenue.

Book a free fit checkAsk how this applies to your business.